Revisiting The Walking Dead, Season 1

Andy

Well-Known Member
Cornerstone Member
Sep 11, 2013
14,514
4,619
14,180
I'm playing through Season 1 of this series again. I'm really impressed by how much they cram into a single episode. Episode 1, for instance, has a ton of interesting dramatic moments and choices. By contrast, more recent Telltale games take a much more leisurely approach to the plot, with only a few major turning points or dramatic moments per episode. But in the first episode of The Walking Dead, I must've been faced with at least a dozen dramatic, difficult moments and choices.

At first, I tended to make the same choices as I did the first time around (I'm still me, after all), but I decided to intentionally make different choices this time around. It does make a difference -- not to the overall direction of the plot, but to how the scenes play out, how the characters react to you, what dialog you hear, etc. After the episode is complete, you'll see an almost 50/50 split on the feedback screens, which is testament to the good job they did in balancing the choices.

They did a great job with Clementine. She is immediately likeable and sympathetic. The dynamic with Lee is very good -- her a small, innocent child trying to come to grips with this brutal world, and him with his demons, trying to take care of her, be honest with her but not overwhelm her (although how she's not overwhelmed, I have no idea).

I was surprised how well it held up, several years later. Not visually, of course, but in terms of the story, the characterization, the tensions/conflicts, the dramatic moments, and the choices. I still think it's their best work.

slide-walkingdead.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: DLC
I've had this game for almost a year, since I bought the telltale bundle at the discount last holiday season and haven't played it yet. I also haven't seen the show at sllall which is kind of why I'm hesitant to play it. Is it ok to play without watching the show?
 
I've had this game for almost a year, since I bought the telltale bundle at the discount last holiday season and haven't played it yet. I also haven't seen the show at sllall which is kind of why I'm hesitant to play it. Is it ok to play without watching the show?

Oh yeah, you can play it without ever watching the TV show. I did. I've never seen a single episode. I think the game is pretty self-contained; it doesn't seem to depend on you knowing things from the TV show.
 
It has no connection to the show which is good because the show is pretty bad. I believe it is tied to the comic but that certainly isn't required by any means.

The story and characters are as enjoyable as any game ever. It was well deserving of its 2012 GOTY status.
 
Only connection it has to show/comic is within episode 1 where meet Hershel, Shawn and Glenn, as those are characters from the comic.
Have not watched the show, but are still reading the comic.

As have said before Season 1 is the best game to me that Telltales have made.
 
The show is bad? Have you no soul, you bastard?

TWD is my most favoritist show ever in the entire world next to BB and Sapranos. I hope you get bit by a zombie on your ass cheeks.
 
The show is bad? Have you no soul, you bastard?

TWD is my most favoritist show ever in the entire world next to BB and Sapranos. I hope you get bit by a zombie on your ass cheeks.

It is pretty much the male version of Twilight. Ok maybe not that bad.
 
Watched the first three seasons of the show I think but yea, it got pretty terrible. Anyways, I have season 1 of this on PC but only beat the first two chapters. Seeing as it will be free via Gold next month maybe I'll actually get around to it sometime.
 
I really like the Walking Dead TV show, but it has gotten a bit stale. For a while now they have just been treading water; introducing new characters, fracturing the plot line, etc. just to squeeze out a few more seasons.
 
game is so freaking good. i agree its their best work so far

i also find huge replayability in it because its interesting to see how scenes play out with different choices of dialogue - not big changes like you say, but just little reactions that help define characters - and also the locations with the fixed camera angles are nostalgic as hell. can't wait to replay it all in preparation for the michonne DLC
 
  • Like
Reactions: DLC and Andy
game is so freaking good. i agree its their best work so far

i also find huge replayability in it because its interesting to see how scenes play out with different choices of dialogue - not big changes like you say, but just little reactions that help define characters - and also the locations with the fixed camera angles are nostalgic as hell. can't wait to replay it all in preparation for the michonne DLC

Oh that's right, the Michonne three-parter is due this Fall. I just did a quick search, and it looks like Nov or Dec:
http://attackofthefanboy.com/news/telltales-the-walking-dead-michonne-game-release-date-teased/
 
Ugh, just finished the last episode. Even though I knew what was coming, those last scenes are heart-wrenching.

I noticed Sean Vanaman was the guy who wrote episodes 1, 3, and 5, which imo stood head and shoulders above the others. I believe he's left Telltale, gone on to do something else. He's a talented writer -- Season 1 wouldn't have been the GOTY award winner it was, without him -- and I'm sorry he's not in their company anymore. He created some unforgettable characters and scenes.
 
I haven't started Season 2 yet due to how well done the final episode of season 1 was. Very good writing and atmosphere down the stretch.
 
If Season 1 was an A, Season 2 is a B. It's good, it just doesn't match the intensity of Season 1. The characters aren't as distinct, the relationships and conflicts aren't as compelling, the dilemmas are less interesting, the dialog isn't as sharp.... It's enjoyable, just not at the same level as Season 1.
 
Decided to finally take the leap. Got through episode 1 so far. You're right, it is good. This is my first game like this so I wasn't exactly sure what to expect but so far I'm finding it to be a great mix between story and playing. It actually almost feels like an escape the room game where you're looking for little pieces of a puzzle to help you move on. I think I'll do an episode or 2 a week.

Also, the decisions are already really hard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DLC and Andy