I would say in presentation and core gameplay, it does live up to the hype for me. Also the constant co-op aspect. I'm a big fan of co-op games and it's pretty rare when they are done well. Where it falls short is on content (variety of content anyway). Granted, I'm only Lvl 11 on Venus, but all of the reviews I've read pretty much say the same thing. I'm interested in the expansions but only if they put out something really worth while (not just more of the same with a higher lvl cap). When I hit the lvl cap (which I likely will), I'll probably not start over as another class unless I have a compelling reason to do so. For the game as is, I'll likely be "done" with it just about the time FH2 comes out. The Crucible is "meh" IMO so that is no draw to me. Rather play Titanfall for MP personally.