An awful week to care about video games

starlight777

Zork Rules
Sep 12, 2013
2,668
718
1,928
An awful week to care about video games
http://www.polygon.com/2014/8/28/6078391/video-games-awful-week

What an awful week for the culture that surrounds and influences video games.

Last week, a game designer's personal life was exposed to the internet, and used to justify physical threats to both the developer and her colleagues. The designer was one of many people targeted in an orchestrated harassment effort directed at game developers.

On Friday, harassers hacked game designer Phil Fish's Twitter account and website. Fish, at least briefly, contemplated selling his company and leaving the industry altogether.

On Sunday, a fake bomb threat from a hacker groupdiverted the flight of Sony Online Entertainment president John Smedley.

That day, the same hacker group claimed responsibility for shutting down Sony's PlayStation Network. According to an official earnings forecast, an attack that shut down the same network in 2011, which lasted for days, cost the company $170 million.

On Monday, prominent media critic, Anita Sarkeesian, posted a video to YouTube that criticized the use of women as background decoration, particularly in violent and sexual ways.
Many of those who shared the post received threats and harassment. The following tweets were directed at game designer Tim Schafer on Tuesday and Wednesday.


@JonTronShow @TimOfLegend can you people just leave my
games alone? No women gave a f*** about gaming pre 2005 can you f*** off please???
— Kamal Noor (@KNoor1997) August 26, 2014
The response directed at Sarkeesian was louder, more aggressive and more dangerous.

Death and rape threats forced Sarkeesian to leave her home for safety. These threats are merely a cross section of the cruel and frightening harassment Sarkeesian has faced in her career.

Yesterday, a SWAT team threw a young man to the ground at gunpoint on a livestream, playing into a plan of online griefers who called 911 with a false report of an active shooter. The Littleton Public School District locked down a number of schools in reaction to the same threat.

Good, positive and kind action happened this week, too. Progress, while not always as loud as repression, is being made in games culture.
Two days ago, GaymerX rebranded as GX: Everyone Games. Its Kickstarter has raised $46,085 at the time of publication for an inclusive video game convention. Sarkeesian's critical videos have helped many developers to reassess how they create games and what they include in them.
And creators outside video games also showed their support for Sarkeesian's work.


This week, it should be clear to this community that games are at a cultural turning point. No longer are games designed, marketed and sold to a niche group of young men. Games are now ubiquitous, their ability to provide a safe space for experimentation and empathic experiences serves a population that, in a time as economically and politically bleak as this one, need them desperately. More games are being created by more people for more people than ever before.

Two groups are at opposite ends of this moment:
One side has folded its arms, slumped its shoulders while pouting like an obstinate child that has learned they are getting a little brother or sister but wants to remain the singular focus of his parents' affection.
The other side has opened its arms, unable to contain its love and compassion, because they understand they are no longer alone.

This week, the obstinate child threw a temper tantrum, and the industry was stuck in the metaphorical grocery store as everyone was forced to suffer through it together. But unlike a child, the people behind these temper tantrums are hurting others. It's time to grow up. Let's not wait until next week to start.




The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of, and should not be attributed to, Polygon as an organization.
 
Don't wait for the Last Judgment. It happens every day. ~Albert Camus, The Fall, 1956
Attitudes are contagious. Are yours worth catching?
A man is rich in proportion to the number of things he can afford to let alone. ~Henry David Thoreau
 
Anita is right. We should take out all six of the women in Hitman: Absolution and only allow you to kill civilian men in the game. The clear hatred against women in games by developers, smh. Anita is causing everyone grief for profit. What a devil she is.
 
Anita is right. We should take out all six of the women in Hitman: Absolution and only allow you to kill civilian men in the game. The clear hatred against women in games by developers, smh. Anita is causing everyone grief for profit. What a devil she is.

Still does not deserve the treatment she suffered. If you do not agre with her then simply put fourth your argument in a clear, thoughtful, and logical manner. Hacking, and sending death threats is pointless and stupid.
 
Still does not deserve the treatment she suffered. If you do not agre with her then simply put fourth your argument in a clear, thoughtful, and logical manner. Hacking, and sending death threats is pointless and stupid.

Quite.

There are many shades of grey here and it doesn't need to be a binary right/wrong stance.

There is no justification for the vile abuse of Zoe Quinn or Anita Saarkeesian but there is justification for disagreeing with their viewpoints, behaviour, conduct or hypocrisy without being branded a sexist abusive pig.
 
  • Like
Reactions: menace-uk-
Anita is right. We should take out all six of the women in Hitman: Absolution and only allow you to kill civilian men in the game. The clear hatred against women in games by developers, smh. Anita is causing everyone grief for profit. What a devil she is.

That's the problem, she plays the game without regard for the rules of the game, to highlight her "opinion". Then claims that's how the developers intend the game to be played, which is then picked up an ran with...
 
Still does not deserve the treatment she suffered. If you do not agre with her then simply put fourth your argument in a clear, thoughtful, and logical manner. Hacking, and sending death threats is pointless and stupid.

Most definitely.
 
Online harassment & threats should be treat (at least at some degree) as any harassment & threat, in my opinion. People just do all kind of nasty stuff online because they can get away with it.

These crazy actions by people are making people wary of creating games anymore, & it certainly make me wary.
 
Online harassment & threats should be treat (at least at some degree) as any harassment & threat, in my opinion. People just do all kind of nasty stuff online because they can get away with it.

These crazy actions by people are making people wary of creating games anymore, & it certainly make me wary.

Just make your game full of dudes and you'll be okay...
 
Still does not deserve the treatment she suffered. If you do not agre with her then simply put fourth your argument in a clear, thoughtful, and logical manner. Hacking, and sending death threats is pointless and stupid.
It's clear no one deserves that BS. It's ridiculous that the gaming community has such a vocal minority. If only laws would be enforced in place to stop such savage behavior.
 
I care about games just like I do every week and not at all about this trumped up drama and sensationalized inequity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frozpot
I think the best way to treat all this drama is to not give it any attention.
 
The death threats and name calling are wrong and pathetic. Having said that with everything happening gaming "journalism" is conveniently leaving out the other side of the story. They are all in bed with the developers, sometimes literally. They often also preach at the gaming community while engaging in acts that cross the line against their proposed higher morality.
Luckily since last year I have weaned myself off of the professional websites. I get my news from here and reddit among other places. I honestly don't see a point to gaming websites. I can watch a press conference live, why do I need their money hatted opinions?
 
The death threats and name calling are wrong and pathetic. Having said that with everything happening gaming "journalism" is conveniently leaving out the other side of the story. They are all in bed with the developers, sometimes literally. They often also preach at the gaming community while engaging in acts that cross the line against their proposed higher morality.
Luckily since last year I have weaned myself off of the professional websites. I get my news from here and reddit among other places. I honestly don't see a point to gaming websites. I can watch a press conference live, why do I need their money hatted opinions?
Did you just change topic?

What has making death threats have to do with Journalist taking favor from Developers (if that can be proven)?
Sure we can discuss it, but keep it in a separate thread.

Its different topic. Also morally wrong, vs making death thread, harassing people & hacking into their account are vastly different in severity, the latter are by definitions, criminal offences.
 
Did you just change topic?

What has making death threats have to do with Journalist taking favor from Developers (if that can be proven)?
Sure we can discuss it, but keep it in a separate thread.

Its different topic. Also morally wrong, vs making death thread, harassing people & hacking into their account are vastly different in severity, the latter are by definitions, criminal offences.
You never cease to make laugh with your topic policing across the threads. Anybody with intelligence would see that these issues have origins, something you obviously cant grasp. I had you on ignore for months with your often negative and banal posts. I'm putting you back because you never add to the conversations, and in fact more often then not I feel dumber after reading one of your posts. May god have mercy on your soul. ;)
 
Death threats & harassment's & hacking into developers accounts have anything to do with game journalists supposedly sleeping with developers as you said? Ok, if you say so. I admit not being intelligence enough to see the direct relation.

Also, I am not attacking you. I am just pointing out that they are different topic & level of severity. If you have think they are related & can provide a good reasoning, I can listen, even agreed.

If people said I am wrong, bias, or even made dumb arguments, & pointed out (hopefully without any name calling) correctly, I can admit my fault, if I offended someone I can apologize. & I have done so before. No biggy. Learn & move on, & be a better person.

What I do not want to do, is to sugercoat things, so sometimes I may came out as harsh. I think its not being honest if I do so.

If I sound like I make an attack on you, or make you feel dumb, I am sorry, that's not the intention.
I also do not intend to 'police' the thread, but you do have a point that I may be trying to hard to prove my point sometimes. I will take note. :)

For instance, I think its not good for the community here to have separate threads for a multiplatform games, especially when more people owning X1. People with PS4 or WiiU of the game will be left in the cold. But of course, not everyone agree, which is fine by my book, & I can respect that, which is also why I never mention that again.

But I will take your advice not to 'police' or avoid unpopular possibility negative views,. ;) I should sleep now.

So to start of a positive post:

I hope tomorrow will be a fine day for everyone here at UnionVGF.
 
  • Like
Reactions: blofeld65
I don't agree with a lot of words from Sarkeesian's overbearing standpoint, but at the same time it's not like gaming community was void of any kind of bull****. She definitely doesn't deserve this.
 
To be fair, making death threat & harassment is not unique to gaming. Cyber bullying usually on social media have been around for a while, even lead to sucide cases, mostly from teens( from reports I seen).

Sense of entitlement while bad, & ranting on Internet is irrating, but doesn't really affect real life. Problem came when people get personal.

Obviously people will have conflict of opinions. That's normal.

Yes, people do sometime say something stupid, offensive either. But that doesn't give one the free reign to make personal attack on them.

I am sure they are a minority, but it's hurting the gaming community when developers start questioning their passion & decided to do something else.
 
Last edited: