I recommend a teamxbox look so people can feel more at home.

Hey guys I found this for XenForo and it looks pretty slick

"Gameing-XenForo-Theme"

http://www.deviantart.com/art/Gameing-XenForo-Theme-4-Sale-204546222

gameing_xenforo_theme___4_sale_by_completegfx-d3ds4vi.png

That's what I am talking about. It would be cool to have this theme.
 
I don't know... I think at least The Union B&W style looks much more Web 2.0 than that screenshot there. I like it more than that.

Don't underestimate the power of white space when it comes to web design.
 
I vote for the green team Xbox color scheme as well. The greyish color scheme at the moment is a little hard on the eyes (my eyes at least).
 
Why on earth would you want this place to look like an old, outdated, and busted version VB like TXB used?