UnionVGF Review: Xbox One Console

Plainview

I am a sinner.
Sep 11, 2013
47,900
25,334
4,279
After some trials and tribulation, my Xbox One arrived on Saturday. I couldn't wait to get that puppy up and going.

The Xbox One box felt solid the moment I picked up it. Once everything was out of the box, my initial thoughts were confirmed. The Xbox One is one solid built machine and Kinect felt equally as solid. The controller, same deal. Every piece of equipment Microsoft put in the box felt like it was built to last, even the HDMI cable. Prodding around each piece, I couldn't see where Microsoft cut any corners with the design and construction. After the "Red ring of death," fiasco, I would hope so.

The size of the console is a tad bigger than the OG Xbox 360, meaning, it's not really big. The cries of it being the size of a '80's VCR,' are unfounded. The console has a sleek design that's very reminiscent of a Harman Kardon piece of gear. The two tone black works very well in most home entertainment systems. There isn't a single negative I can point out when it comes to the design especially the cries of the system being too big.

The Kinect technology has matured and so has the design. The Kinect that comes with the Xbox One fits the overall package. It blends in perfectly with the console itself. With that, it also blends in with the rest of your entertainment system. The only thing missing is a TV mount. I'm not sure why one isn't out with the launch but Microsoft needs to get one out along with a wall mount.

I have a love and hate relationship with the Xbox One controller. Part of me sees it as one of the best controllers ever made for FPS, racing and sports. The other part of me thinks it's quite possibly the worst controller ever made for fighting games. After the disaster the Xbox 360 controller is for fighting games, that's saying a lot.

Call of Duty: Ghosts worked very well with the Xbox One controller. Movements were precise and aiming felt really good. The shoulder buttons are easier to access for me since I don't have to take my finger off the trigger and can nudge it with my knuckle. Have to take my finger off the trigger to press the shoulder button is far different than on the Xbox 360 controller. It's kind of a struggle and awkward for me. I have big palms and shorter fingers. Since I don't have to take my finger off anymore, it's not really an issue. The thumbsticks feel more sensitive than the Xbox 360's thumbsticks. It took a few rounds of CoD: Ghosts to get used to them, but once I did, it felt like heaven.

Now, why is the Xbox One's controller so bad for fighting games, it doesn't handle certain motions very well. Through out my years I've always had a problem pulling off a "Dragon Punch," motion with most controllers going right, except for the holy grails, the Sega Genesis six button and Sega Saturn controllers. I'm deadly going left. Not sure why. Direction d-pads like the Xbox One controller and PlayStation d-pads would always cause me the most trouble. With the Xbox One controller, it's beyond a chore to pull a dragon punch motion off and even a fireball motion going in either direction. This makes playing anything but charge characters a near impossibility for me. I asked a friend of mine who's also a big fighting game fan if he felt the same, he did. He felt the d-pad was a major step backwards from the Xbox 360's controller. It's a big shame because everything else about the controller is near perfection.

The trigger rumble is a cool addition. As someone who doesn't use rumble at all I found myself actually liking it. Having said that, I think I will be turning it off for everything but Forza Motorsport 5. That is... Once I figure out how to turn off that feature!

Overall, I'm very happy with what Microsoft has done with the Xbox One. It's a sleek and stylish machine that blends into everything I have in my entertainment system. The Kinect follows the lead set by the Xbox One and I have no problems keeping it as part of my entertainment system. The Xbox One's controller is a mixed bag. It's great on one end of the spectrum, racers, sports and FPS's, and seemingly everything else, but really poor on the other, fighting games. I expect Microsoft to do a revision to the controller that has more of a floating d-pad that was on Xbox 360's controller. Geez, I never thought I would see the day where I'm asking to use the Xbox 360's controller for a fighting game. Please Microsoft, give us a functional Xbox One d-pad. The controller is perfection otherwise.
 
Nicely written. Please do one on the Kinect 2. Including TV integration. Thanks Plainveiw, Im still out of town and it'll be at least a week before I get my hands on mine.
 
Have you tried out the voice commands yet PV? They work really well for me. I had an issue with controlling 2 program using the snap feature, but thanks to a tip on here Ive got that figured out. Its like a shock to the senses if you are used to the dashboard on the 360, and takes a little time to get used to.
 
Nicely written. Please do one on the Kinect 2. Including TV integration. Thanks Plainveiw, Im still out of town and it'll be at least a week before I get my hands on mine.
I put up another review about the OS and UI. I haven't tried out the TV integration yet. That's for later today with the NFL. Now, more game playing!
 
Glad to see that you finally got the console. Welcome to the big time!
 
Very much enjoying mine as well, got a new tv too and at first had hooked it up to the old TV with DISH going through the new Xbox and was hoping I'd have no issues with the new Panasonic TV. Had been worried about having issues getting that to work with DISH and having to look up remote codes and go through all the stuff I remember seeing the DISH guy do when he set everything up for us years ago. Just set up everything through the Xbox One and that's all we had to do so that was a relief. Only had one weird issue when I went to try out Xbox Fitness and the Party option thing was connected to it on the side so that I thought it was just part of Xbox Fitness because I couldn't get rid of it. Then after I went back to the Home screen everything I tried to use it was still there. I don't think it was snapped because it was from the top to bottom of the screen and not the little square "snap" window". End up exiting out of the Xbox and going back in and it was gone. Don't know if I accidentally hit on Party when I was trying to do Xbox Fitness but if anyone can tell me how to get out of that next time without shutting down the Xbox that would be great! I didn't think to try doing the "unsnap" command because I didn't even think of that.

But overall my husband and I are quite pleased with it, he even commented about it being "not as big" as he expected it to be. Couldn't believe how easy it was to set up.
 
V much enjoying mine as well, got a new tv too and at first had hooked it up to the old TV with DISH going through the new Xbox and was hoping I'd have no issues with the new Panasonic TV. Had been worried about having issues getting that to work with DISH and having to look up remote codes and go through all the stuff I remember seeing the DISH guy do when he set everything up for us years ago. Just set up everything through the Xbox One and that's all we had to do so that was a relief. Only had one weird issue when I went to try out Xbox Fitness and the Party option thing was connected to it on the side so that I thought it was just part of Xbox Fitness because I couldn't get rid of it. Then after I went back to the Home screen everything I tried to use it was still there. I don't think it was snapped because it was from the top to bottom of the screen and not the little square "snap" window". End up exiting out of the Xbox and going back in and it was gone. Don't know if I accidentally hit on Party when I was trying to do Xbox Fitness but if anyone can tell me how to get out of that next time without shutting down the Xbox that would be great! I didn't think to try doing the "unsnap" command because I didn't even think of that.

But overall my husband and I are quite pleased with it, he even commented about it being "not as big" as he expected it to be. Couldn't believe how easy it was to set up.

The party snap does run down the whole right side of the screen, to get it off just say "xbox unsnap". Or you can press the start button and turn the app off from there. When you have an app snapped press the home button twice on your pad to swich your controller to the different app.
 
The party snap does run down the whole right side of the screen, to get it off just say "xbox unsnap". Or you can press the start button and turn the app off from there. When you have an app snapped press the home button twice on your pad to swich your controller to the different app.


Thanks - that will be helpful if that happens again!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Two Pennys Worth
Good read. Thanks Plainview for confirming what i already expected. Nothing but quality from Microsoft. Can't wait to get my One.
 
I'd give it a solid 9/10.

OS/UI are slick, the games I've played are great, talking with a buddy on chat is much better as the audio quality is much better than 360, the controller is solid like always and the tv snapping is great. I've barely even used the voice commands yet. And Kinect 2's image quality is much better than K1. It's not crystal clear, but the image of yourself when it calibrates K2 is leagues better than whatever K1 did. And the system itself isn't as humongous as everyone thought it would be. Looking at my Panasonic BR home theatre system and my Rogers Nextbox 2.0 cable box, X1 is a smaller footprint on my media stand than either of them. Also, X1 is very quiet. You can barely even hear it when skimming the dashboard. When playing a game, you won't hear it at all.

OS drawbacks are no controller battery indicator, no HDD remaining space indicator and these BR games take forever to install. Makes sense they take longer than 360's 7gb DVD games, but the wait is still long. I guess I can try playing the game when it hits the threshold "ready to start", but I prefer just waiting for everything to install in order to ensure everything is ready to go.
 
Last edited: