That tweet might be the dumbest criticism possible
I responded to a couple losers in that Tweet, but it's really just mostly a circle-jerk of absolute hatred, in there. I learned that "Guy-ladriel" is a thing they call her, and once the dude I was asking about what that actually means, had actually referred to her as GINO (Galadriel In Name Only
), I had to peace-out... the anti-RoP brigade reads like a F-ing cult! I'm all for criticism, but many make points based on nonsense, and pretend they are Tolkien experts, claiming it breaks lore (and I'm not saying that it 100% doesn't) It's just that most don't seem to understand that MOST of the 2nd age is kind of a blank slate. Tolkien references things that happen in it, but the show's role is to tell new stories, starting with the elves we know, and eventually introducing the wizards and Sauron, and the forging of the rings of power, inching us closer to what we know about the 3rd age... although, still THOUSANDS of years away, until the The Hobbit!
... "But, but Galadriel never went to Númenor?" How do you know, MF? She sure AF existed, back then! There's like this whole Atlantis that existed, and none of these Immortals went there to at least VISIT there? EVER? It's just a bunch of people repeating the same nonsense.
So it's not the criticism, it's that when you see people devoting SO much time rallying against sh!t they don't like, it's just F-ing weird, and absolutely cultish! We know that SW has been through this weird ass "Mary Sue" people phase, and yes, there's been a mixed bag of content, but at one time, it was a fierce and focused hate brigade. You've gotta wonder who's turning the wheels and gears behind this sh!t! It FEELS political, and mostly because they somehow CLAIM that the content itself is too political... Makes you wonder.