Sure but he is the biased one and it was posted here as if there was something egregiously wrong with the pcgamer articleJez is just as justified to disagree with that guy's opinion as that guy is to post it. She is creating a strawman argument.
Everyone is justified to an opinion but what is the point in saying that when many on this forum has decided that anyone that didn't declare it the best game of all time deserves some kind of scorn?