Xbox one for me. I'm really big into competitive multiplayer games so the best online gaming experience is the number one thing I'm looking for. IMO you cannot beat what Xbox is offering as far as dedicated servers go and just the whole Xbox live experience. also it's worth $500 more for me to never again have to see a rhythm shattering host migration message pop up numerous times in the middle of the same match!!! or have somebody dashboard on you and you lose all of your stats for that match.