For whom? I know not for me.
Mine is based on hands on experience, not a picture.
It's all good.
The DS4 is super comfortable. SOOO much more comfortable than the DS3 was.
Luckily, I am looking at the controllers from a different viewpoint. While the DS4 is light years better and more comfortable than the DS3, it still fails to dethrone the Xbox One controller. First and foremost for me, is the ease and comfort using the controller. The Xbox One beats my DS4 hands down in that area. Secondly, battery life. Not even sure if the DS4 has a battery life, when you compared to the X1 controller. It's just that bad. Hopefully dimming the light bar will improve that. It would be nice if the DS4 would go into low power mode once you set it down immediately, like it does on the X1 controller, to save battery life. I will take the comfort, ease of use, battery life and quality of the X1 over my track pad on my DS4, even with the added button benefit the DS4 pad is offering. At this time, the only thing I ever use the track pad for (unless the game mandates the use of it) is for the onscreen keyboard. Using it for that is awesome.
Ok, I can't nor will I set here and tell what you should desire in the comfort of a controller. That is simply a matter of opinion. I can only tell you that my experience is much different here. Do I think the XB1's controller feels great? Absolutlely! Do I believe it's handles feel better than the DS4? Yes they do - by a slight edge, but there is a small problem, though. Where it gains this advantage, it comes at a sacrifice. I feel the shoulder buttons are MUCH harder to hit due to the outter, sharp angle of the handles; they put your palms into a natural resting position just to force the index fingers to reach up and towards your face rather than just reaching at the natural diagonal position. So, for me, it loses in this case. But again, that is just my own opinion.
Now, what I can tell you are the facts, and the fact is the DS4 is a far more advance controller than the X pad. Wether or not you dislike the pad because of it's battery or comfort is irrelevant. The FACTS still stand. These controllers are on two different planets when it comes to specs under the hood of them. The specs in the touch pad alone is equivalent to having a 2nd DualShock controller at your disposal. We are not talking one or two buttons here. The amount of inputs available to this thing it closer if not beyond ten. Don't take my word for it, though. Here, take a peak at just some of the basics of the track pad:
https://support.us.playstation.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/5048/~/how-to-use-a-dualshock-4
Now then, take this quote into consideration that these basic inputs work for more than just the oversized button beneath it:
"You might not have realized this, however, but it is also one giant button. It only has one general click, but the system knows where you’re pushing. This enables developers to map different parts of the touchpad to be different “buttons” that you can press. For example — and this is something launch title and first-person shooter Killzone: Shadow Fall does to control its OWL drone — a game can have four commands here, one on each edge (top, bottom, left, right). So if you press down on the right side of the touchpad, you could activate a different behavior than if you press down on the left side (and so on)."
http://venturebeat.com/2013/10/24/t...-design-and-everything-else-part-4-exclusive/
.......and ALL OF THEM can coexist at once. Factor in the motion sensors in the controller and the X pad is completely out of it's league. Its like an Atari 2600 joy stick competing with the controllers of last generation (MS Sony).
On another note, before the analogue sticks, we could have easily said that we didn't need them over the D pad if we never saw anyone put them to use. But now that we have, I'm willing to bet that it wouldn't be as easy for those very same individuals to go back to the D pad.