Time To B1tchslap Each Other: Who Won E3 2014?

Who Won E3 2014?


  • Total voters
    82
  • Poll closed .
So because MS won this poll means all who voted for it are fanboys ? Xbox fans and xbox fanboys are very different things. I also am not sure why you think any of the other 2 should have beat it out this poll. The sony show was no better than MS, and like it or not, Nintendo are not big players. They had a fluke last-gen, but most gamers tend not to give a crap about them.


Perhaps time for some to calm down a bit. Who wins this poll or that poll or E3 is rather irrelevant to the big picture. Lets all just rejoice and be thankful for all the awesome games we saw from the conferences. In the end, we are the real winners.
For the most part its some ignorance or fanboyness yes. The Sony show was much better then MS and the internet wide polls show this.
 
I haven't read through it all....

I will say internet wide Sony and Nintendo are winning in the who won E3 polls over MS who hasn't won any polls besides here.

People are entitled to their opinions, people also said Sony won last e3 as well and I think that was even worse than this years.

Beyond delusional! Just look at the who won E3 poll results.

I voted for MS because they're bringing exclusives this year that I actually am psyched to play, games that make the console worth owning this holiday.

By the end of this year I will have played Halo 1, Halo 2, Halo 3, Halo 4, Halo 5, Sunset Overdrive, Forza Horizon 2, Fable Legends and Ori. All awesome, all exclusive and I don't know how anyone who owns both consoles couldn't be excited about that.

I'm not going to condemn anyone for the games they want, but I have the option to play all of the multiplats that are coming to PS4 on my Xbone, besides that the exclusives leave a lot to be desired for this year. If Uncharted, Blood Born and the Order were coming out 2014, we'd be having a different conversation but for 2014 I that's just how I see it.

Does that make me an Xbot? I think it's a perfectly reasonable perspective to have given that information.
 
  • Like
Reactions: starlight777
For the most part its some ignorance or fanboyness yes. The Sony show was much better then MS and the internet wide polls show this.

Fanboy... How about you shut your face, and help me out with strategies to defeat the demon dog and spider :D:D
 
Except this forum was made to be more open. Just saying it would be nice to have Sony discussions without people that hate the company, have absolutely no interest in it, or outright lie. Maybe the same goes in the Xbox forum but I never go there so not sure. I'd like to but right now I'm pretty harsh on MS and some of their choices lately, so when I question that I'm labeled a fanboy. Either you're 100% for their choices or GTFO.

Anyways, my personal feeling is thread bans should be handed out a lot more or if possible just outright banning people from certain sub-forums.
I agree.
 
I would say Nintendo (surprisingly). They were the only ones to surprise me.

MS and Sony had many great games and the Xbox One and PS4 are much better consoles than the Wii U due to third party support alone but they pretty much showed everything that I expected them to show. I could have predicted 75-80% of MS and Sony's E3 2014 conferences last year.

Wii U had unique looking games outside of Zelda and I was surprised by that. So yeah, Nintendo "won" in my opinion.
 
For the most part its some ignorance or fanboyness yes. The Sony show was much better then MS and the internet wide polls show this.

I typed "who won E3 2014" into google. First page, couple of sites say Nintendo, a couple say Sony, a couple say MS... most of the Sony won sites say by the smallest of margins.

This year, no way was there a clear cut winner. Each show had its merits and failures. MS's was constant games, no megatons. Sony had some shocks, but sagged with boring parts in the middle, Nintendo were just their every E3 selves.
 
People are entitled to their opinions, people also said Sony won last e3 as well and I think that was even worse than this years.



I voted for MS because they're bringing exclusives this year that I actually am psyched to play, games that make the console worth owning this holiday.

By the end of this year I will have played Halo 1, Halo 2, Halo 3, Halo 4, Halo 5, Sunset Overdrive, Forza Horizon 2, Fable Legends and Ori. All awesome, all exclusive and I don't know how anyone who owns both consoles couldn't be excited about that.

I'm not going to condemn anyone for the games they want, but I have the option to play all of the multiplats that are coming to PS4 on my Xbone, besides that the exclusives leave a lot to be desired for this year. If Uncharted, Blood Born and the Order were coming out 2014, we'd be having a different conversation but for 2014 I that's just how I see it.

Does that make me an Xbox? I think it's a perfectly reasonable perspective to have given that information.
Well I own both and MS didn't show much worth mentioning for my tastes coming in 2014...
Forza Horizons is way to soon Sunset looks comically goofy/corny,Fable Legends I am interested in but is it even coming this year and could possibly be a letdown as I Loathe the other Fable games and Ori is not my type of game.They didn't ease concerns of the technical limitations in anyway as most of what they showed was pre-rendered To me MS put on a way better show last year then this year.BTW Those 3rd party games will prob look and play better on the PS4 and that's reason enough for anyone who mainly plays 3rd party games to get a 4.
 
I typed "who won E3 2014" into google. First page, couple of sites say Nintendo, a couple say Sony, a couple say MS... most of the Sony won sites say by the smallest of margins.

This year, no way was there a clear cut winner. Each show had its merits and failures. MS's was constant games, no megatons. Sony had some shocks, but sagged with boring parts in the middle, Nintendo were just their every E3 selves.
Don't make me come back with links..
 
People are entitled to their opinions, people also said Sony won last e3 as well and I think that was even worse than this years.

People said Sony won last E3 because of the price and DRM situation.
 
BTW Those 3rd party games will prob look and play better on the PS4 and that's reason enough for anyone who mainly plays 3rd party games to get a 4.

...Unless they are, you know, interested in more than just 3rd party games. Halo Collection for example may very well be the Xbox One's "Mario All Stars". Incredible value there. PS4 and Xbox One should do very well this Holiday season.
 
I said Dark Souls?
Or Demon Souls. But we were comparing Halo 5's possible sales to Bloodborne and you used Dark Souls (maybe 2) as an example because Bloodborne is to be similar.
 
...Unless they are, interested in more than just 3rd party games. Halo Collection for example may very well be the Xbox One's "Mario All Stars". Incredible value there. PS4 and Xbox One should do very well this Holiday season.
You fall into the obvious pick category your pre-show video and bans @ gaf show this.
You should stop
 
Or Demon Souls. But we were comparing Halo 5's possible sales to Bloodborne and you used Dark Souls (maybe 2) as an example because Bloodborne is to be similar.
I said Bloodborne could/would possibly outsell Halo 5 the next game in the declining series.
Uncharted 4 most definitely will outsell H5 as TLOU R will outsell Halo MCC.
bookmark this post
 
Well I own both and MS didn't show much worth mentioning for my tastes coming in 2014...
Forza Horizons is way to soon Sunset looks comically goofy/corny,Fable Legends I am interested in but is it even coming this year and could possibly be a letdown as I Loathe the other Fable games and Ori is not my type of game.They didn't ease concerns of the technical limitations in anyway as most of what they showed was pre-rendered To me MS put on a way better show last year then this year.BTW Those 3rd party games will prob look and play better on the PS4 and that's reason enough for anyone who mainly plays 3rd party games to get a 4.

How is Horizon too soon? The last one came out two years ago.

Also Fable Legends is coming this year. All games that are coming out this year, they showed gameplay.

If you prefer TLoU and Driveclub and slightly better looking multiplats over all of that, that is fine and well. I'm not going to call you a Sonybot for the opinion.
 
You fall into the obvious pick category your pre-show video and bans @ gaf show this.
You should stop

:meh: ...I chose Nintendo for my "winner".

"Bans at GAF"? I've never been banned multiple times on GAF.

Maybe you should stop.

Make an on-topic reply to a post and get attacked out of no where lol. Wow.
 
I said Bloodborne could/would possibly outsell Halo 5 the next game in the declining series.
Uncharted 4 most definitely will outsell H5 as TLOU R will outsell Halo MCC.
bookmark this post
Bookmarked. I'll say you'll maybe get half right.
 
:meh: ...I chose Nintendo for my "winner".

"Bans at GAF"? I've never been banned multiple times on GAF.

Maybe you should stop.

Make an on-topic reply to a post and get attacked out of no where lol. Wow.
Oh I know as it would be to obvious to pick MS after such a bad showing but you picked MS over Sony. Yes you have been banned at gaf for your stealth trolling

It is on what the topic has become and that is Xboys voting based on bias..I jumped into the convo didn't start it.
 
I said Bloodborne could/would possibly outsell Halo 5 the next game in the declining series.
Uncharted 4 most definitely will outsell H5 as TLOU R will outsell Halo MCC.
bookmark this post

If that doesn't happen it would be absolutely pathetic considering the console installbase difference.
 
Oh I know as it would be to obvious to pick MS after such a bad showing but you picked MS over Sony.

"Obvious after a bad showing?" Who made you king of all E3 opinions? Sony was the only one to show media/apps at their conference and it killed the flow of their show. So yes, I think MS did better than Sony at E3. If Sony didn't do the media/apps talk, I would have thought that Sony had a (slightly) better show overall than MS.

Yes you have been banned at gaf for your stealth trolling

Stealth trolling? No. I got banned for making a reply in a Trials Fusion 900p resolution thread about why a person could still be attracted to a console that didn't have the best looking third party games in its gen. Me bringing up PS1, PS2, and PS3 to prove that point was somehow thought as "off topic" though.

So if you are going to talk about my temporary ban at GAF (for some off topic, random reason) you could at least get the reason for it right.

It is on what the topic has become and that is Xboys voting based on bias..I jumped into the convo didn't start it.

So me choosing Nintendo as the winner is "bias"? I stated my reason for choosing them in my post. What is your problem?
 
"Obvious after a bad showing?" Who made you king of all E3 opinions? Sony was the only one to show media/apps at their conference and it killed the flow of their show. So yes, I think MS did better than Sony at E3. If Sony didn't do the media/apps talk, I would have thought that Sony had a (slightly) better show overall than MS.



Stealth trolling? No. I got banned for making a reply in a Trials Fusion 900p resolution thread about why a person could still be attracted to a console that didn't have the best looking third party games in its gen. Me bringing up PS1, PS2, and PS3 to prove that point was somehow thought as "off topic" though.

So if you are going to talk about my temporary ban at GAF (for some off topic, random reason) you could at least get the reason for it right.



So me choosing Nintendo as the winner is "bias"? I stated my reason for choosing them in my post. What is your problem?
It was multiple posts as pointed out by other gafers (lol now it was some random reason)
You own XBO/Wii U so yeah you picked the two you own over the console you say you see no reason to buy in 2014(even though u play many 3rd party games)
 
How is Horizon too soon? The last one came out two years ago.

Also Fable Legends is coming this year. All games that are coming out this year, they showed gameplay.

If you prefer TLoU and Driveclub and slightly better looking multiplats over all of that, that is fine and well. I'm not going to call you a Sonybot for the opinion.
You actually have to ask me why a new Forza in less then a year after F5 isn't to soon!? Come on bro. TLOU I prefer strongly and Drive Club I don't care for(rather have F5) but will DL the free version. LBP 3 looks great and if Fable Legends is coming and plays better then the other terrible IMO games in the series..I am very excited for it. Sunset looks dumb(i wanna be wrong)
 
It was multiple posts as pointed out by other gafers (lol now it was some random reason)

Multiple posts? "Pointed out by other gaffers" like who? What are you talking about?

You own XBO/Wii U so yeah you picked the two you own over the console you say you see no reason to buy in 2014(even though u play many 3rd party games)

:meh: A bought a Wii U last year after Nintendo's horrible, laggy/choppy Nintendo Direct.

You seriously make no sense what so ever. And yeah, I don't see a reason to buy a PS4 in 2014 when all of the PS4 games I'm interested in come out in 2015 and the Xbox One will have all of the third party games I'm interested in. Not spending $400 just for "better AA".
 
  • Like
Reactions: pravus