As much as the focus is new IP for Xbox, ironically I think this E3 is going to hinge on Halo more than ever. Halo is probably Xbox’s best chance at a short term resurgence but only if it’s disruptively good.
God of War and Zelda BOTW are currently the games of this generation and both scared old fans at first when revealed. Halo needs an evolutionary reboot. While I agree that Halo needs to grow and change, I don’t think 343 has brought about the right kind of change. 343 has made it clear they’re never going back to the slower paced, boots on the ground, no sprint Halo’s. Halo 5 is the new sandbox they want to build off of. While I disagree with this (and quite honestly am a bit sad about it) I think if they’re going to speed up Halo, they should throw the entire linear campaign in the garbage and go full speed into their own thing.
I think Spartan Powers destroy the classic simplistic sandbox but could bring about exciting campaign changes if they stop trying to pigeonhole them into a linear, typical cover shooter that many other mainstream FPS campaigns have done to death.
343 is Microsoft’s most expensive studio with their most valued franchise. 343 has to be able to deliver a 9.0 metacritic quality campaign.