If you purchased a 4K HDR Blu-ray player wouldn't you get a 4K monitor to take full advantage of that expensive product ? it's not rocket science.. Sure it will work on a 1080 P television, but what would be the point ?But we're not just talking about 4K. The interviewer was asking about benefits on a 1080p set. He flat out said no benefits at all. Phil could have clarified "you'll see increased graphicaly fidelity on 1080p sets but not Scorpio's full potential" or along that line instead of "buy the Xbox One S, no benefits for you from the Scorpio if you have a 1080p set."