It wasn't debatable. I saw all first hand, on both systems. Nothing could touch Ryse.That was debatable then vs TR PS4 and BF4 PS4 all 3 of those games were on equal footing.
Crysis 3 PC rapes RYSE XBO though. Heck id throw in Dragon's Crown PS3 that year as it was gorgeous and 1080p/60fps but art usually doesn't get the nod.