The Xbox One Thread v3.0

Status
Not open for further replies.
mrtapout said:
looking at the average fps, x1 is 29.84, and capped at 30, this means, it rarely drops frames. Not even 1 frame less than the 30 it is planned at. PS4 aimed at 60, average is 50, so this means it drops to 40 often, and holds 60 also. The inconsistency is what hurts the ps4 experience.
Click to expand...

043b17f8ac4866a58acd0a687bb812ed
 
mrtapout said:
looking at the average fps, x1 is 29.84, and capped at 30, this means, it rarely drops frames. Not even 1 frame less than the 30 it is planned at. PS4 aimed at 60, average is 50, so this means it drops to 40 often, and holds 60 also. The inconsistency is what hurts the ps4 experience.
Click to expand...

did i just read that because the ps4 rate of 50 drops to 40 which is still 10fps faster than that of the xbox ones 29, that the xbox is better because it only dropped 1fps even though thats still 10 lower then that of the ps4?

seriously!

and isn't there a ps4 v. xbox one thread somewhere?
 
blue said this conversation should be else where Yoyoniner. So if you want to keep fighting this stupid fight go there.

There is an update coming up in March and I rather talk about that with the X1.
 
mrtapout said:
top one is 60 bottom is 30. Watching the digital foundry video though the ps4 version drops to mid 40s quite often and even as low as 30. A fluctuating framerate is very annoying. Anyone play NBA 2k on 360 should have experienced when playing is smooth 60 but camera cuts after shots would drop to high 30s. It was very distracting.
The difference between tombraider on xbox and ps4 is largely due to different studios developing both titles and one deciding to cap at 30 while the other for ps4 aimed at 60 and was unable to lock. Polygon gave x1 version an 8.0 and ps4 version a 7.5, saying the x1 version was more consistent and less distracting. Digital foundry made a similar analysis.
Click to expand...
Really I just read the Polygon review and they got the same score but they said "And while the two releases are otherwise mechanically identical, if pressed, we'd recommend the PS4 version's generally better performance."
 
I think the comparisons should stop in this thread, Plainview already stated many times to avoid comparison here.
 
Hazard71 said:
Really I just read the Polygon review and they got the same score but they said "And while the two releases are otherwise mechanically identical, if pressed, we'd recommend the PS4 version's generally better performance."
Click to expand...

So mrtapout lied.
 
Was ghosts DLC released today it says I've downloaded it with my season pass. I've went to the store it says I own it. But I can't access any other maps on extinction mode.
 
morfeeis said:
did i just read that because the ps4 rate of 50 drops to 40 which is still 10fps faster than that of the xbox ones 29, that the xbox is better because it only dropped 1fps even though thats still 10 lower then that of the ps4?

seriously!

and isn't there a ps4 v. xbox one thread somewhere?
Click to expand...

A tv shows 60 fps, a game running at 60 fps is oc the best, second best is 30 fps, a picture every second frame on the tv. A game running 40 or 50 aren't good, it can give screen tearing on the tv bc it's not in sync with a tv's framerate
 
Starting to get into extinction mode on ghosts. Bought the season pass. Hopefully between that DR3 DLC, Killer Instinct, I'm set until H5. Might get TF have to rent first.
 
Hissatsu said:
Considering the avg fps is 50 I find it hard to believe that it drops to 40 "quite often". Btw the team behind the ps4 version helped with the xb1 version as well. For some reason everyone keeps ignoring that fact while quoting different dev team excuse from same article.
Click to expand...
Yeah they helped them which says x1 version was not done by veteran pros like ps4 version yet it came out great. You don't know what they helped with for all you know it could be just menus or actual code.
 
kb said:
Any game that drops to 19fps is not a 'judder free experience', nor is any game that has tearing (as the XB1 version does). It seems that the two devs did have differing opinions probably because it was tearing monstrously before it was limited to 30fps and most likely didn't go much higher then that most of the time.
Click to expand...
Drops under 30 on couple of occasions where ps4 version constantly drops and with average being 52fps it should of been locked at 50 for more consistent gameplay then when the game drops fps into 30s it won't be as bad as going from 60 to 32
 
Only on Union can you find xbox fanboys trying to basically say lower fps is better.
 
Yoyoniner said:
How is this better?

BfQV3oa.png
Click to expand...
How is it not? Again using an old image from DF which they corrected to 24fps and with average of 29.84 vs 50.98 says that xbox average is .5% lower than intended while ps4 average is 15% lower than intended and with such massive jumps from 60fps to 33fps its wayy worse than even from 30 to 18. This tells you that ps4 version is not anywhere near as consistant as x1. This is not consoles fault but devs fault
 
Going by all the TR frame rate analysis, PS4 wins, but really depends if you care about fluctuations. X1's version holds 30 fps almost all of the time. That's why DF's avg rate was almost 30 fps at 29.xx fps. A few dips but 30 fps almost all of the time. PS4 maxes oiut at 60 fps, but has wild fluctuations to 40 to 50 sometimes. The avg is about 50 fps.

If you're someone who cares a lot about frequent fluctuations, X1's is better. If you're fine with unlocked frame rates and don't mind 30-60 fps swings, than PS4 is better.
 
theBADguy said:
Well where else will he do his viral marketing?
Click to expand...

Hey if you don't want PS4 fans in this thread it is pretty simple: How about stop discussing PS4 games? It never started with anyone else but an Xbox One Superfan. We never discuss the Xbox One in the PS4 thread at all--let alone make up (lie) about Polygon reviews and scores.

Have fun...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Squiggs
We can't eject a disc or turn off the X1 with Kinect, right? I know you would have to get up anyway to retrieve the disc but these seem like logical features for Kinect.
 
Yoyoniner said:
Hey if you don't want PS4 fans in this thread it is pretty simple: How about stop discussing PS4 games? It never started with anyone else but an Xbox One Superfan. We never discuss the Xbox One in the PS4 thread at all--let alone make up (lie) about Polygon reviews and scores.

Have fun...
Click to expand...
Oh please. No mention of the Playstation could happen and you'd still be in this thread, you people simply can't help yourselves, lol of course you aren't discussing the xbox in playstation threads since you're too busy hanging in xbox related threads s***ting them up. Go figure...
 
This isn't directed at anyone in particular (imo, both "sides" have problems not engaging in this) -- but Plainview and Blue have both asked you guys to stop with the X1 versus PS4 talk in this thread. There are plenty of other threads for that. In fact, I think at one point we had 3 different threads just discussing X1 vs. PS4 TR graphical differences, which is a ridiculous abundance, a gleeful fanboy paradise of graphic whore arguments to participate in.

Let's try to keep this thread for discussion of the X1.
 
If you are a PS4 fan....in here defending the system...I ask you why are you in the XBOX DISCUSSION and in the XBOX THREAD?
We have a multiconsole subforum for you.....it doesn't make sense other than to troll..
If you have a beef with what is brought up here vent in the subforum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back