But that's the core point I disagree with. Fundamentally any machine might well be able to do that but we are talking about a video game console in the era of call of duty/halo. When Xbox gamers talk about wanting a machine that gives developers an easier way to achieve better games the meaning should be pretty f***ing obvious. We're not talking about Pong or PacMan. We're talking about FPS and twitch games. Generalising to include games no one is actually talking abut and then blaming that on presumptive conversation is just silly.
You know what you want from Scorpio. So do I. I'm not expecting 4K native 60 FPS for a next gen shooter but I am expecting the best that be done because now the tools are available to the developers.
But are you disagreeing with? You know this stuff. It's infinitely obvious that Scorpio versions will be the best versions unless a dev completely drops the ball. The specs alone pretty much guarantee it. The minimum quality would be Xbox one level, but seeing as there is another base console version to target, I'd wager even the laziest version for Scorpio would be at least PS4 quality.
My guess is that minimum spec for Scorps would be on par with the Pro though. I mean, it's already made, and a larger install base would direct that to get the focus.
Hell, we already get COD and BF at 60fps on current consoles, so there is no reason to believe that would change. A more solid framerate is a given, I would think. I definitely think we will be seeing a lot more games go for the Dynamic Resolution angle to maintain framerate. Beyond that, the highest sellers may well be twitch games, but that doesn't mean other types aren't where to find money, so they are definitely in the equation.
Upping FPS is also not the only way to make a game better. For twitch shooters, yes, but there are games that benefit more from immersion or physics, or vast, detailed open worlds. You can't make blanket statements where there isn't one way to do things.
You are right, no one is talking about Pong or Pacman, but certainly Halo will. If it runs 1080/60fps on the One, it'll run 4k/60fps on Scorpio. I'd love to see FH3 at 60fps, but I'd wager that would mean no 4k. It would be awesome to have the option though. It's certainly too early to know what they are going to do, and I doubt Flynn is even allowed tell you anyway, though everything he has said has been what I expect.
As stated by Flynn before, EXPECT it to go thusly:
If Xone can do it 1080p/60 fps, Expect Scorps to do 4k/60ps
if Xone does it 1080/30 fps, Expect Scorps to do 4k/ 30fps
That is not Pacman or Pong, but it's not Crysis either.
I just hope they go the option route, but as he has said before, some engines are built around specific framerate (my guess is for optimization reasons), then they would have to totally re-write to do more. Hopefully game in future will be built with this in mind.