"More logical," lol. Ok. Sounds kind of arrogant. To me, it's just your opinion, and everybody has their opinion (usually they think their opinion is more logical, too).
You usually have an opinion that is very different than the norm, which imo is good from a reader standpoint, because it makes the discussion more lively. Nothing more boring than everyone agreeing on everything.
Anyway, about the PS3, you're right of course, it was a big disappointment to Sony. I said that. This is really not a unique Jackie perspective at all, but commonly held opinion. It was way below their expectations and a lot of people considered it a blunder out the gate, especially in terms of pricing. I think that eventually, though, it could be considered successful console -- not as successful as they would have liked, certainly, but in the long run, it sold very well and by anyone's standards left behind a very respectable game library.
I don't think it's an either/or thing, as if something is either "a success" or "a failure" and that's the end of the discussion. It was a failure in some ways and a success in others.