Maybe maybe not. I think the truth is somehere in between.
I am not commenting that everything the video said are correct, I personally think some of the point made are quite reasonable, like showing off more games, to show Kinect capability. Some points, maybe not completely agreed. We can agree to disagree, thats not an issue.
The underlining point I wanted to made is that the video isn't about MS being doomed with XBOX one, like some people think (wonder if they even watch the video), but about what MS can maybe do better.
Saying that its better to take action early when a gap is there, then later when it potiential widen further, is purely my own opinion. Its ok to diagree (though I find it hard to argue against the logic, unless they are more concern of profit per xbox, than selling more, & gain profit from games & services).