Mostly agree. I think their messaging was wrong. Everyone was hyped to see ‘next-gen gameplay.’ Bad choice of games for that!
After watching all the trailers a few times, I’m more excited about some of them. But the show itself was too much hype and too misleading. All eyes on Sony now, but I also think this will push the MS July show to really be a showcase of what they have lines up.
Hopefully they learn from this, I think one reason they went with this format is because this is what they've been doing at E3 for the last couple of years and they think it works. It's easier to just put a bunch of 2 minute highly edited trailers together than to give each game time to show what it really is. That's why personally I've found their last couple of E3's to be a forgettable mess, people brag about quantity but they don't worry about quality.